Links
TheReefTank
proudly awards
this site as
Recommended Reading
Please vote for it
in the community!
Vote for us!
proudly awards
this site as
Recommended Reading
Please vote for it
in the community!
Vote for us!


Over-Stocked?
Page 1 of 1 • Share •
Over-Stocked?
I think my tank is alittle over-stocked, will the LFS take back a few fish.
i have
4 dalmation mollies
14 neons
4 cardinal
4 swordtails
1 plec
4 cherry barbs
2 tiger barbs
1 clown loach
2 female betta
4 silver tips
i have
4 dalmation mollies
14 neons
4 cardinal
4 swordtails
1 plec
4 cherry barbs
2 tiger barbs
1 clown loach
2 female betta
4 silver tips
Storm- Rosetail

- Posts: 565
Points: 691
Join date: 2009-05-28
Age: 23
Location: Carlisle UK
Re: Over-Stocked?
Hey Storm.
Its not over-stocked if its a big tank, but is over-stocked if its a small one
In other words, what size is the tank? 
Its not over-stocked if its a big tank, but is over-stocked if its a small one
Re: Over-Stocked?
Its a 3 and a half foot width tank.
Storm- Rosetail

- Posts: 565
Points: 691
Join date: 2009-05-28
Age: 23
Location: Carlisle UK
Re: Over-Stocked?
Thats what like a 29 gallon? over stocking aside the mollys would prefer slightly salty water, the plec may get massive depending on breed and the loach will eventualy need a much much bigger tank as well as the fact that he/she would prefer some friends.

Newfishy- Moderator

- Posts: 774
Points: 811
Join date: 2009-05-27
Location: USA-PA
Re: Over-Stocked?
Ive always kept 1 loach, however i think the tank is bigger than 29g. Once the loachs get to a fair size, my lfs swaps them for a smaller one.
. The mollies are doing fine without salt, its the longest ive ever kept mollies they must be nearly a year old.
Storm- Rosetail

- Posts: 565
Points: 691
Join date: 2009-05-28
Age: 23
Location: Carlisle UK
Re: Over-Stocked?
hello
Mollies and salt I know nothing about as they are probably my least favorite fish
Most 3ft tanks range between 29-35 gallons depending on the other dimensions. Personally, Clowns shouldn't be kept singularly as they are very socialable shoaling fish, and do need a good swimming area. I would see about rehoming?
With the Clown gone, I think the stocking level isn't too bad. I'd maybe look at something like one of the Botia loaches? The Polkadot ones are nice:)
Mollies and salt I know nothing about as they are probably my least favorite fish
Most 3ft tanks range between 29-35 gallons depending on the other dimensions. Personally, Clowns shouldn't be kept singularly as they are very socialable shoaling fish, and do need a good swimming area. I would see about rehoming?
With the Clown gone, I think the stocking level isn't too bad. I'd maybe look at something like one of the Botia loaches? The Polkadot ones are nice:)
Re: Over-Stocked?
Ok Andy i will lok into that, my lfs should swap them over no bother lmao.
OMG how can you not like the molly lol.
OMG how can you not like the molly lol.
Storm- Rosetail

- Posts: 565
Points: 691
Join date: 2009-05-28
Age: 23
Location: Carlisle UK
Re: Over-Stocked?
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.] the same way i dont really like Swortails, Platties, Neons and Guppies.
Re: Over-Stocked?
in my particular area mollys dont agree with the local water supply and die pretty quite without massive intervention and constant salt use. that and the fact that the first mollys I had where huge bullys makes me dislike them.
I like plattys alright. tims work is having livebearers for a dollar so I will get a few new ones cause my big tank has a grand total of 8 fish in it. I had been keeping the stocking super low because I wanted to raise some bettas for it, but I need a new male, mcgyver wants nothign to do with baby making anymore.
I like plattys alright. tims work is having livebearers for a dollar so I will get a few new ones cause my big tank has a grand total of 8 fish in it. I had been keeping the stocking super low because I wanted to raise some bettas for it, but I need a new male, mcgyver wants nothign to do with baby making anymore.

Newfishy- Moderator

- Posts: 774
Points: 811
Join date: 2009-05-27
Location: USA-PA
Re: Over-Stocked?
what type of plec is it if its a common it will get well to big for the tank. like van said the clown loach will have to go. the tiger berbs will need to go aswell they need to be kept in groups of atleast 6 or they will be extreamly agressive and it to they will start nipping other fish and i think the tank is a little to small for them. you need to have atleast 3 female bettas aswell. how many lph is your filter because you do have alot of tetras?
most of the mollys you get in shops now dont actually need salt and adding salt to the tank makes no diffrence to them. they used to be brackish but they have been breed in freshwater for so long that all the once you get in shops are perfectly adapted to it and dont actually need the salt.
most of the mollys you get in shops now dont actually need salt and adding salt to the tank makes no diffrence to them. they used to be brackish but they have been breed in freshwater for so long that all the once you get in shops are perfectly adapted to it and dont actually need the salt.

kizno1- Moderator

- Posts: 4923
Points: 5198
Join date: 2009-08-20
Age: 17
Location: Norfolk, England
Re: Over-Stocked?
Thanks for the info guys, i have taken your comments on board and im sure the LFS will take some off my hands.
Thanks
Storm
Thanks
Storm
Storm- Rosetail

- Posts: 565
Points: 691
Join date: 2009-05-28
Age: 23
Location: Carlisle UK
Re: Over-Stocked?
The tiger barbs where a pressi from my sister, she went into buy a hamster cage and seen the 2 fellows by themselves and she bought them lol.
Storm- Rosetail

- Posts: 565
Points: 691
Join date: 2009-05-28
Age: 23
Location: Carlisle UK
Re: Over-Stocked?
Thats it then........everything must go and you should have a dozen Tigers [You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
Re: Over-Stocked?
LOL i love tiger barbs there so enagetic.
Storm- Rosetail

- Posts: 565
Points: 691
Join date: 2009-05-28
Age: 23
Location: Carlisle UK
Re: Over-Stocked?
if you do keep the tiger barbs then you need to get atleast 4 more but you might have to get rid of some fish to get them. do you know what plac it is?

kizno1- Moderator

- Posts: 4923
Points: 5198
Join date: 2009-08-20
Age: 17
Location: Norfolk, England
Re: Over-Stocked?
Commen plec. They have not not attacked anything as yet and ive had them for nearly 2 months.
Storm- Rosetail

- Posts: 565
Points: 691
Join date: 2009-05-28
Age: 23
Location: Carlisle UK
Re: Over-Stocked?
its not about them attacking other fish its just tyhey should grow 1 foot + and they grow and poo like crazy that really needs to go as soon as you can. how many lph is your filter?

kizno1- Moderator

- Posts: 4923
Points: 5198
Join date: 2009-08-20
Age: 17
Location: Norfolk, England
Similar topics» Understocked?
» 125 African Cichlid
» Fully stocked 75 (switched the yellow tang for a niger trigger)
» 125 African Cichlid
» Fully stocked 75 (switched the yellow tang for a niger trigger)
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum






