Links
TheReefTank
proudly awards
this site as
Recommended Reading
Please vote for it
in the community!
Vote for us!
proudly awards
this site as
Recommended Reading
Please vote for it
in the community!
Vote for us!


are my new couple OK
Betta-Paradise :: Bettas :: Betta Talk
Page 1 of 2 • Share •
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2 
are my new couple OK
i have one male called bruce, and he's lived alone for about 3months, today i bought a female to keep him company, and i have noticed that the female hides away alot, i was watching them earlier and i noticed that all the male seems to do is sneak up on her, whilst flaring alot, and then dart at her when shes about an inch away, is this normmal, or am i goin to wake up to a dead fish tomorrow
please help

cammeronlaud- Plakat

- Posts: 56
Points: 114
Join date: 2010-02-06
Age: 17
Location: england
Re: are my new couple OK
males and females should never be kept together. he will kill her or she will kill him. again they should never be kept in the same tank and can only be bred under specific conditions and even then the males and females often maim and kill each other.

Newfishy- Moderator

- Posts: 774
Points: 811
Join date: 2009-05-27
Location: USA-PA
Re: are my new couple OK
i was told that they would be alright, i thought it was just males that shouldnt be kept together
ive got nowhere to put her, does anybody know of a quick homemade divider, i dont have any spare tanks, and need to make one asap and the shopes are closed now 

cammeronlaud- Plakat

- Posts: 56
Points: 114
Join date: 2010-02-06
Age: 17
Location: england
Re: are my new couple OK
What size is your tank?



SheenaShoup- Feathertail

- Posts: 1123
Points: 1185
Join date: 2010-03-02
Age: 37
Location: Juneau, ALaska
Re: are my new couple OK
60litre

cammeronlaud- Plakat

- Posts: 56
Points: 114
Join date: 2010-02-06
Age: 17
Location: england
Re: are my new couple OK
you could float a plastic tub in the tank and put her in it, or use a baby net as a divider. even putting her in a large glass bowl for the evenign will be better then leaving her in with him.

Newfishy- Moderator

- Posts: 774
Points: 811
Join date: 2009-05-27
Location: USA-PA
Re: are my new couple OK
Hi
Yeh, Newfishy has told you the correct & safest info here. For every few people that claim they have kept males and females together, there are hundreds that have ended up with a disaster on their hands.
It is possible in a massive tank, but even then its not ideal. I'm guessing that a fish shop told you it would be ok?
Yeh, Newfishy has told you the correct & safest info here. For every few people that claim they have kept males and females together, there are hundreds that have ended up with a disaster on their hands.
It is possible in a massive tank, but even then its not ideal. I'm guessing that a fish shop told you it would be ok?
Re: are my new couple OK
I agree with Newfishy.

SheenaShoup- Feathertail

- Posts: 1123
Points: 1185
Join date: 2010-03-02
Age: 37
Location: Juneau, ALaska
Re: are my new couple OK
BTW
hope you enjoy your time here! 
hope you enjoy your time here! 

SheenaShoup- Feathertail

- Posts: 1123
Points: 1185
Join date: 2010-03-02
Age: 37
Location: Juneau, ALaska
Re: are my new couple OK
oh dear
sorry you got told the wrong info. I was once told that males and females could be kept together too
welcome to the site
welcome to the site

Haych- Feathertail

- Posts: 1134
Points: 1317
Join date: 2009-10-25
Age: 28
Location: Tamworth
Re: are my new couple OK
its sometimes told to new fish owners that males and females can live together. in the normal aquaria its just not possible.
the only situation i have heard of is a little old man from thailand that had a massive plant and betta buisness, he placed one male and one female in a massive fish pond that were also his plant grow out tank. think like 3 foot deep 8x8 wide pond. he allowed them to spawn naturaly. then he would scoop all the 2 months olds out and put the parents and the younger generations of fry back in the pond. his show fish and anything older then 2 months was jarred sepertaly.
the only situation i have heard of is a little old man from thailand that had a massive plant and betta buisness, he placed one male and one female in a massive fish pond that were also his plant grow out tank. think like 3 foot deep 8x8 wide pond. he allowed them to spawn naturaly. then he would scoop all the 2 months olds out and put the parents and the younger generations of fry back in the pond. his show fish and anything older then 2 months was jarred sepertaly.

Newfishy- Moderator

- Posts: 774
Points: 811
Join date: 2009-05-27
Location: USA-PA
Re: are my new couple OK
As the others have said, keeping ,ales and females together is a disaster waiting to happen. Even in the cases where they don't fight, having a male around really stresses the female out - so much so that she could get sick or even die from the stress.
Many people who don't actually know much about bettas (but think they do, because they have kept them or tried breeding them) will tell you that males and females will be fine together. This is often because they have only done it a few times and never had a disaster. However, knowing about how bettas behave and how they interact in the wild tells us that it isn't a good idea at all.
Remember - there is a difference between genuine knowledge and experience and someone who puts them together, doesn't have a disaster and then recommends it to others.
Many people who don't actually know much about bettas (but think they do, because they have kept them or tried breeding them) will tell you that males and females will be fine together. This is often because they have only done it a few times and never had a disaster. However, knowing about how bettas behave and how they interact in the wild tells us that it isn't a good idea at all.
Remember - there is a difference between genuine knowledge and experience and someone who puts them together, doesn't have a disaster and then recommends it to others.

Assaye- Rosetail

- Posts: 509
Points: 662
Join date: 2009-07-28
Age: 23
Location: York/Bucks
Re: are my new couple OK
When i first kept bettas i was told by the fish shop that you could keep a male with three females as it reduced the aggression, i did keep them together for a time, until i read tons of info on them and realized it was the wrong thing to do for the well being of the fish. Once i changed them around they were much happier!
Now all my males are housed separately and the females have a large well planted tank. I also occasionally keep some of the females individually.
Now all my males are housed separately and the females have a large well planted tank. I also occasionally keep some of the females individually.
Re: are my new couple OK
Hope you found a solution to this problem... many LFS's seem to say males and females can be kept together unfortunately 

silverrabbit- Moderator

- Posts: 2556
Points: 2788
Join date: 2009-09-08
Age: 25
Location: London, UK
Re: are my new couple OK
bad news. By the time i read the post, i tried to find the female, she was cowering in a plant, ive got her out, and her fins and tail are a right state, ive quarentined her, and im going to try to nurse her back to health,, im going to try to do something about the fish store, surely thats cruelty to animals or something...thanks everyone, atleats shes got a bit more a chance at survival

cammeronlaud- Plakat

- Posts: 56
Points: 114
Join date: 2010-02-06
Age: 17
Location: england
Re: are my new couple OK
Sorry to hear about your girl
for really bad fin damage I find the eSHa 2000 med really good. If you have some of that you could give it a try

silverrabbit- Moderator

- Posts: 2556
Points: 2788
Join date: 2009-09-08
Age: 25
Location: London, UK
Re: are my new couple OK
clean clean clean water, very little stress and low lights and noise. like not have her tank in a busy room will help her calm down and regrow.

Newfishy- Moderator

- Posts: 774
Points: 811
Join date: 2009-05-27
Location: USA-PA
Re: are my new couple OK
if she was going to die from stress how long would it take, shes been alive on her own for 3days now :/, and i noticed today shes bleeding on her side, i hope she pulls through it

cammeronlaud- Plakat

- Posts: 56
Points: 114
Join date: 2010-02-06
Age: 17
Location: england
Re: are my new couple OK
Newfishy wrote:clean clean clean water, very little stress and low lights and noise. like not have her tank in a busy room will help her calm down and regrow.
Ditto....what Newfishy said plus patience. Just give her time to settle and with very very clean water her fins will start to grow back but it does take time.
_________________
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.][You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
Re: are my new couple OK
Also, if she is bleeding don't use any aquarium salt and maybe add some Stress Coat to help her. So sorry she got so badly beat up Cammeronlaud!
I will put in a special prayer for her!
I will put in a special prayer for her!


SheenaShoup- Feathertail

- Posts: 1123
Points: 1185
Join date: 2010-03-02
Age: 37
Location: Juneau, ALaska
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2 
Similar topics» couple id's please. always fun
» Just bought a couple books
» Frostclan Couple Themesongs
» FS/FT-Hap sp Ruby Green/Ship/OR +couple others
» Couple of scorpion mating pics :)
» Just bought a couple books
» Frostclan Couple Themesongs
» FS/FT-Hap sp Ruby Green/Ship/OR +couple others
» Couple of scorpion mating pics :)
Betta-Paradise :: Bettas :: Betta Talk
Page 1 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum






